matthew w's Profile

Display Name: matthew w
Member Since: 4/4/07

Latest Comments...

soho park was built new/not reused - it was built in a lot where they tore a building down a couple years ago.


Apartment Therapy New York | Look! Industrial Garage Lights in a Restaurant
6/24/09 11:21 PM

anyone else notice the 5 columned porch? don't see that very often.....


Apartment Therapy New York | Rustic Country from Designer David Cafiero
5/18/09 2:42 PM

This is the last posting I'll make on this and I'm done.

1. Henrietta has it right. We shouldn't design houses one way because of an uneducated eye. It doesn't matter if someone uneducated from a distance can tell if the house is old or new. it's completely irrelevant. We shouldn't design one way because there are uneducated people. Second, if you knew Millbrook, the house isn't even visible from the road.

I can respect what you're saying about Fred and Ginger, I understand why the site is there, and I understand a building needed to be placed. But as far as sympathetic (except for the height) i couldn't disagree more. It's a complete object building fighting to distract attention from the row and focus it on that corner. It's what gehry does best - build object buildings. One could argue that Bilbao was contextual, but the other seven or eight exploding pieces of steel were just dropped into an open lot.

And my last point. This isn't some suburban house. This is no 'McMansion.' This isn't a poorly designed house. This home required years of work, countless years of knowledge & research, and is built the right way but the right tradespeople (you should look up a little more information on Gil than the article gives). It involved a level of craft rarely seen at this time and it was done right. It's well proportioned, well thought out and every decision purposeful. It's not a careless attempt to add 1-800-columns (yes, it exists) to your home or add a frivoulos classic architectural mouldings and designs where they don't belong. I will agree with you, that's when a problem comes in - when pieces of classical architecture are used in the wrong way simply for decorative 'effect' with no knowledge of why they are placed - just to add faux character.

This, Mr. Schafer simply has not done.


Apartment Therapy New York | Greek Revival Style: A New Old House The New York Times 1.30.09
2/1/09 11:34 PM

mschatelaine:

Your comment just doesn't make much sense to me. So how can one always stay new? You do realize people still build houses that look like houses these days, right? And what about windows? By that reasoning shouldn't we not use those anymore because they've been done?

The problem is quite the opposite - the need to be different. The need to design something out there, out of context 'as a response to our times' and new because we want it to be different or an object. He couldn't find the home he wanted, so he built one out of the character and style of the region to be sympathetic with the context and style of the time.

You're comment about the Fred & Ginger is what disappoints me the most. To have a beautiful stretch of buildings broken up and then add on an object building right in the middle to scream 'look at me.' Gehry respected the height I'll give you that- though I'm guessing that's more to do with the historical nature.

Gil's not trying to pass off new as old. He's not trying to fool anyone. He's just not the type of person to be different just for the sake of being different. There's a reason why homes use to be built this way.


Apartment Therapy New York | Greek Revival Style: A New Old House The New York Times 1.30.09
1/31/09 11:21 PM

@ ridge_van_winkle

that's a nendo cappellini ribbon stool.


Apartment Therapy New York | How To: Build a Colorful Winter Bed
1/17/09 7:30 PM

retailmenot.com

the single best coupon store. Complete with accuracy ratings so you don't have to guess if it will work or not.


Apartment Therapy Chicago | Tips for Shopping Online During the Holidays
12/8/08 7:30 PM

yeah. way to redeem yourselves AT. :)

I'd need 2 though. one closed and one open.


Apartment Therapy New York | REK Extending Bookcase by Reinier de Jong
12/3/08 1:34 PM

the dwr tools for living shop has them in stock in nyc.


Apartment Therapy New York | Roundup: Cycloc Bike Racks on Apartment Therapy
11/19/08 3:38 PM

You might want to note that this is NOT a replacement in the cinema line - it's a monitor for the MacBook line only. There is no dvi port on the monitor at all, only mini DisplayPort for the new 3 MacBooks.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Survey: Apple vs Dell Display Showdown
10/27/08 4:22 PM

Had anyone seen this from this summer?

http://www.theonion.com/content/news/new_linens_n_shit_opens

Maybe it's less funny now....


Apartment Therapy New York | Hot Tip: Linens 'n Things Going Out Of Business Sale
10/20/08 12:09 PM

Just a forewarning - it's not solid aluminum. The top is a thin piece of aluminum on mdf and it dents and scratches all over. It's actually pretty poorly built.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Go Aluminum! MUJI Table at MoMA
9/30/08 8:59 AM

someone should tell them their name looks like mediocre.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | MEdiaCOre: The Living Room PC as Furniture
9/25/08 11:25 AM

Garrett said what i was going to. It would be fine if the knob had a more flattering shape and a better finish.


Apartment Therapy New York | Hot or Not? Wood Inlaid Door Knobs
8/27/08 2:25 PM

if you read the comments at engadget, and looked at the mini usb port on the bottom you'd probably be able to tell this is a complete fake. That's a five minute CAD model.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Next-Gen Nano Silicon Case Reveals a New Shape
8/25/08 9:27 AM

it's revolting. especially when you see it from across the river and how it breaks the natural flow of the riverbank. I'm all for object buildings, just poor location.


Apartment Therapy New York | Look!: Modern Architecture in Prague Washington DC
8/18/08 1:30 PM

sort of been around for years.....

http://www.shakeawake.com/product_info.php?products_id=29


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Silent Alarm Clock
8/18/08 9:44 AM

i'll take a kidde silhouette any day.

i wish the guys at architectural devices got their design off the ground.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Snap Alarm Tries, Fails to Improve Smoke Alarm Design
8/14/08 1:36 PM

i'll take a kidde silhouette any day.

i wish the guys at architectural devices got theirs together. oh well.


Apartment Therapy Unplugged | Snap Alarm Tries, Fails to Improve Smoke Alarm Design
8/14/08 1:34 PM

Citarella sells it in New York.


Apartment Therapy The Kitchn | Do You Know This Beer? Whale's Tale Ale from Nantucket
7/31/08 3:23 PM

yeah, but most of those aren't going to meet the code on this side of the Atlantic.


Apartment Therapy New York | EeStairs EeDesign: Sculptural Stair Designs
7/28/08 10:33 AM